In very marginal contacts in the UKACs, my Echo sometimes gets mistaken as Tango, and my Yankee is sometimes misheard as Japan.
England and Yokohama usually overcome the problem, but I tend to stick to the correct phonetics otherwise.
Mickey, I’d be VERY careful if I were you. If you REALLY are advocating the use of alternative phonetics, then you need to be aware of the amount of times you identify as 2E0TYP!
If people regularly hear “charlie” or “delta” when you say “golf” then
that would suggest you’re not saying it properly.
I wonder how DB7MM could be misheard as DB7MA several times in the recent WAE DX Contest.
In reply to AX3AFW:
I admit to abandoning the standard if the other op fails to read my
call after two attempts and use something for his area if I can -
Europe gets Amsterdam Florence (or France) Warsaw the US gets America
Florida Washington.
So do I. Only if several attempts of Delta Bravo 7 Mike Mike fail, I switch over to Mexico, Mexico for the suffix. Denmark, Baltimore is only necessary in very rare cases.
Otherwise I stick to the NATO-alphabet as required by Radio Regulations. In fact this is the only one allowed officially.
BTW: I share the fun of spelling my name with 2E0YYY. “Name is Mike like Mike, India,…”
I wonder if that’s why several people think my name is Mike? “My name is Tom - Tango Oscar Mike”. Mike is often troublesome. (Interpret that however you like). Old-timers often insist on hearing it as Golf, when stated as my prefix. Mexico provides assistance.
M is also a nuisance prefix on CW, especially when it is followed by an unusual number like 1. It can be difficult to persuade South American or Caribbean DX stations that they have heard M1 and not W1.
There is another phonetic alphabet I have heard, often attributed to soldiers during the Great War. It would be fun to try it out during a contest, as it is probably the very antithesis of the intent of such an alphabet. I cannot recall all of the meanings, but a few will show what I mean -
A fer 'orses
C fer miles
F fer vescence
Q fer hours
R fer pint
T fer two
No, or possibly also, this is the phonetics used by the Desert Rats in North Africa. The story as told to me by one of them many years ago in the pub (of course!) is that their simple crystal controlled radios had the same channels as used by the Germans, so everything they said was overheard and spurious messages could be received. Using this phonetic alphabet they succeeded in keeping their unwanted listeners confused! They also frequently changed between alternatives to stop the enemy from catching on, and I seem to remember that some of the alternatives were rather more vulgar than those quoted…
Xenophobia - the fear of people who are different from one’s self. I’ve always pronounced that with a Z… maybe that’s just being from Nottinum. Wonder how they pronoun it in Issix.
When I was in Cyprus Zulu Charlie Four Echo Echo caused some people difficulties on ssb. The zulu was mistaken for zero even though that didn’t make sense. My favourite combination of Zanzibar Canada Four England England seemed to work well, though it probably made a lot of purists cringe!
One more note on the topic most operators do not know: NATO alphabet should not be pronounced in English but in a defined way. This helps multiple nations understand it properly, one example is OSCAR which should be pronounced like “oh-scar” instead of “asker”. Just look it up on wikipedia.
…listening to and working lot’s of pile-ups, my experience is, that a mix of different alphabets is more confusing than helpful.
From my SOTA-activators side, there is one special station in my mind:
Don, G0RQL - listen to him - slowly and well pronounced he breakes every pile-up - hi.
There is another phonetic alphabet I have heard, often attributed to
soldiers during the Great War. It would be fun to try it out during a
contest, as it is probably the very antithesis of the intent of such
an alphabet. I cannot recall all of the meanings, but a few will show
what I mean -
A fer 'orses
C fer miles
F fer vescence
Q fer hours
R fer pint
T fer two
Xenophobia - the fear of people who are different from one’s self.
I’ve always pronounced that with a Z… maybe that’s just being
from Nottinum. Wonder how they pronoun it in Issix.
73, Gerald G4OIG
i wouldn’t know gerald i’m from maccesfield n chesher, nice one on the spelling its better than some of the posts lol.
best 73s sean