G0SLQ
13 July 2012 00:11
1
Can anyone advise by what criteria they are chosen? - is it height, location, boundaries?
Just seems a few high-spots in the vicinity which I thought were high weren’t listed. Perhaps they have to be remote from roads and have trig points?
Just curious;-)
Steve
In reply to G0SLQ:
I think it has to be 150 feet all the way round.
Ricky MW6GWR
G8ADD
13 July 2012 01:58
4
In reply to G0SLQ:
This is covered in section 3.5 of the SOTA General Rules which can be downloaded as a pdf from the website. In the UK there has to be an ascent of at least 150 metres from the highest col (saddle) to the summit, this is known as the prominence of the summit. Some Associations in areas with few significant hills (such as the Netherlands) are allowed a prominence of 100 metres.
73
Brian G8ADD
OH7BF
13 July 2012 10:07
5
In reply to G0SLQ:
Can anyone advise by what criteria they are chosen? - is it height,
location, boundaries?
Hi Steve,
The topographic prominence is not so easy to understand, but is fairly rigorous criteria as far as I can see.
In topography, prominence (also referred to as autonomous height, relative height, and shoulder drop in US English, and drop or relative height in British English) measures the height of a mountain or hill's summit relative to the lowest contour line encircling it but containing no higher summit within it. It is a measure of the independence of a summit. The key col ("saddle") around the peak is a unique point on this contour line and the parent peak is some higher mountain, selected according to...
Note also that the x-axis in Fig. 1 is seldom a straight line in nature.
73, Jaakko OH7BF/F5VGL
G4OOE
13 July 2012 18:22
6
In reply to G0SLQ:
Hi Steve
In the UK I believe it is based on Alan Dawson’s book, The Relative Hills of Britain and the hills of 150m prominence are known as Marilyns.
73
Nick G4OOE
G0SLQ
13 July 2012 21:40
7
Thanks for the replies and the email;-) So as well as Marilyns and Munro(e)s - are there any Normas, Jeans or even Bakers I need to know about lol.
Best leave the WOTA’s well alone for the time being.
Cheers all
Steve
G4OOE
13 July 2012 22:33
8
There are various categories of hills, check out www.hill-bagging.co.uk
Cheers
Nick