Other SOTA sites: SOTAwatch | SOTA Home | Database | Summits | Video | Photos | Shop | Mapping | Sotlas | FAQs | Facebook | Contact SOTA

Sacrifice boots and Shoe Goo

10 years back I went to Madeira for the first time and a walking friend said “don’t take good boots, the lava will destroy them”. Fair enough I bought a cheap pair of Karrimor Mount Mid boots and also did not want to use a load of my luggage allocation moving heavy boots. In the end I never did much rough walking in Madeira. The boots were comfy but not on stony rough ground, the sole is not thick or tough enough. After 3 summits in Lanzarote and a few near my sister’s QTH near Nimes, I retired them from SOTA. Just not enough sole and the lugs on the tread wore away quickly. I still wear them around town.

In 2016 before visiting Fuerteventura I moved “upmarket” to a pair of Karrimor KSB200 boots. Much more support and a stiffer, thicker sole. These worked fine on 2x OK, 1x SP and 1x DM summits and then did fine also on 2x EA8/FU summits. I wore them for dog walking as well. However, by summer 2017 the sole had split from left to right and started to detach on one side. They were under warranty still but actually getting Sports Direct to act was a little challenge, a suggestion of “new pair or refund or I’ll see you in the Sheriff’s court” did the trick. The replacements did 10x FL/VO, 2x DM, 5x F/PE, 2x F/CR, 13x OK, 1x SP and 2x EA8/FU summits. However, again the sole started to fail in EA8/FU, a 9km walk resulted in several tread lugs breaking off. So considering I got a replacement pair at 10months and I think I got my money out of them, just.

That would be that but I’d read about repairing soles with Shoe Goo. I’d tried fixing the KSB200 with Evostick adhesive but it shrinks a lot as the solvent evaporates so is good at sticking things together but filling holes or missing pieces of tread. I bought 4x 5ml tubes of Shoe Goo to test it out. 4 small tubes because I’ve had enough tubes of gunk in my life to know one big tube may well “go off” once opened or end up the lid stuck on.

Having cleaned up the shoe, one 5ml tube was enough to build up the sole where the three tread lugs had broken off. I’ve been using them for dog walks and seeing how the Shoe Goo holds up. The result is remarkably well. For a start Shoe Goo is dimensionally stable, it doesn’t shrink when the solvent evaporates. Whilst the instructions say it takes at least a day to set, it starts to set within minutes. That means you get to apply it and maybe touch it up once. After a few minutes trying to shape it will make a mess so don’t. I did the repair 6 weeks ago and have worn the boots for many dog walks and it’s still stuck where it should be stuck. This includes pavement/sidewalks, forest trails, fields, gravel/hardcore tracks with the distance getting on for 50kms.

From this single test we can extrapolate that Shoe Goo works perfectly :slight_smile: Well no, but it seems so far to be doing what it says on the tin. I cannot say the same for the boots. Looking at the soles, I can see the tread is starting to fail in the same way the originals failed. I think you can expect to get about 200-250km out of a pair of KSB200 boots before they simply start to fall apart. It’s not poor workmanship but poor quality materials. So yes, they are a sacrifice boot but maybe there are better and cheaper sacrifice boots. I hope to be getting out to EA8 nearer Christmas so I think I’ll try something cheap from Decathlon or may be use my old TNF Hedgehogs which have taken one hell of a beating till the soles wore down, they’re still 100% waterproof though.

Shoe Goo :+1:
Karrimor KSB200 :-1:

Why did I bother trying Shoe Goo on them? Well it’s a good test to see if Shoe Goo works and the KSB200 are really quite comfy. A few more weekends walking the dog and they’ll be toast.

6 Likes

I’ve found superglue works well on trainers. I’ve heard it can even be used to close wounds, although it sounds like it would sting like hell. I fixed my antenna with superglue in Tenerife this Christmas and it’s still fine.
73 de OE6FEG
Matt

2 Likes

Somehow I’m not a fan of cheap shoes.

I have never found some in my tests in outdoor stores which give the ankle the necessary support and the step the right grip and are robust enough. Since I would not have a good feeling when hiking (eg over scree or wet sloping rocks) … especially if I still carry loads.

I belong to the group of shoe - murderers… No idea why. Maybe my walking style is so special … (in combination with my weight :thinking: )

All shoes that are cheaply made cause me back pain over time and they break quickly. This is also the case with low shoes.

Maybe it makes more sense to invest in sturdy good shoes than to keep buying cheap ones.

My hiking boots are, depending on the weather and terrain: Lowa Tibet GTX and Scarpa Mescalito Mid TRK GTX … which have now lasted a very long time. If necessary they get new soles

73 Armin

2 Likes

I used to use Karrimor walking shoes for light to moderate hill walking but found them to wear out too quickly. I now use Gelert Ottawa, which are a few quid cheaper and the soles grip better and give me about 18 months of frequent use (including 2 miles a day of pavement pounding with the dog!)

With regard to shoe Goo, I must look for that. I still have a pair of alpine boots (insanely expensive!) that I used for rock and ice climbing forty years ago, still in good nick and wearable and on their second pair of soles, held on with screws and black Araldite (can you still get that?)

1 Like

Yes, for proper boots I have spent a small fortune on Meindl and Asolo boots. This is specifically about boots for use on CT3 and EA8 very abrasive lava where you don’t want to do irreparable damage to your expensive boots.

Karrimor of old is not the same as the Karrimor owned by Sports Direct. They put a name that had lots of prestige on cheap products now.

1 Like

Shoe Goo also makes an excellent mastic for sealing around cable entries, antenna joints and so on, because it doesn’t shrink. I used some for that purpose about 5 years ago when I had run out of silicone and it’s still holding up well despite being exposed to UV

It doesn’t seem to go off in an opened tube either - I have a 60ml one from a few years back that is still usable

Rick

3 Likes

…and that is where the problem lies. I still have karrimor goretex jacket and sallopettes from the proper company. Very expensive and high quality. I wouldn’t buy anything out of Sports Direct if I could help it. Tbey bought up brands in distress just to get the name. The quality is rubbish.

3 Likes

And that’s the problem…

If you take brands whose suppliers are, for example, Goretex, Polartec or Vibram… you can not really do anything wrong.
These suppliers are a bit more expensive… but usually deliver good quality.

In my experience, the general quality of the brands suffers as soon as these suppliers are replaced by cheaper ones.

73 Armin

4 Likes

Tell me about it! I was thrilled by those Karrimor shoes, they were the most comfortable ones I’d ever had, but they wore out much too rapidly. I used to buy their gear back in their heyday, too. Tempus Franjit!

2 Likes

I’d second that Fraser. The stuff from Sports Direct is generally poor. Unfortunately it seems as though there’s not much choice these days as it seems that all the brands we know are now under the same company umbrellas.

JD Sports for example- trading under many names, such as Go Outdoors, Millets Blacks, Ultimate Outdoors etc

Being a true Yorkshireman, it pains me to spend money, but I do have an eye for the nicer brands. I buy a fair amount of gear from Magic Mountain, which is the Outdoor and Sports Company outlet shop. OSC owns Mountain Equipment and Sprayway brands among others. There’s often sample sales where you can get good kit in good fabrics at half retail price or less. For example the Gore Tex Pro jacket I bought last year cost me £180, whereas the same jacket in the shops on the high street is priced at £400.

I’ve recently been looking for some lightweight hiking boots but I just don’t seem to be able to find any. I ordered sone La Sportiva Ultra Raptor IIs but the fit was no good for me, so they got sent back. I’d spent ages researching the size too. My 18 year old Scarpa SLs are now getting quite tired, I’ve looked at the new SLs, but Scarpa changed the last and now the new ones don’t fit :frowning:

I’m a bit stuck because I want better quality than available at Sports Direct and the local shops want silly money! ( I guess its not their fault, they’ll be struggling like the rest of the high street).

Colin

2 Likes

Boots are a tough one. Cairngorm granite has shredded my £220 Meindl Bhutans in just 2 years, but my 25 year old Scarpa Mantas are still going strong. They’re made of unbelievably thick leather and only see use in winter conditions.

As for clothing, I’ve mainly moved away from wearing Gore-tex, finding Paramo more durable and flexible, Buffalo better for cold winter summits and OMM better for lightweight and summer trips at the expense of durability and features.

Of course, having three sets of clothing means that it should all last longer, as each component is receiving less wear and tear.

3 Likes

I have a pair of Scarpa SL M3’s i think they are from back in 2005 i think. I don’t use them much the past 10 years, but they are still going strong and my main hiking boots. Ive heard Scarpa use different lasts now and are a little cheaper in the build quality and leather thickness etc but i do believe that companies make things so they break quicker so you buy them again. For waterproofs i had a montane eVent waterproof which is great and very breathable and i bought a montane Goretex jacket in December and was surprised at how Goretex just doesnt seem as breathable. The issue i had with eVent is the jacket is a lightweight jacket and just not as durable. Now i wear the Montane eVent only if its raining and I’m coaching rugby in the rain!

2 Likes

Have a look at Keen Targhee III Mid Waterproof Boots. I was looking for some TNF Hedgehogs having had great success with the shoe version. For long and complex reasons I ended up with a £100 voucher for Cotswold Outdoor. So they only cost me £25. They’re a light fabric boot. They don’t come up as high as my Meindl boots. They seem comfy and whilst I’ve only tested them on dog walks (grass, forests, roads, tracks) they feel OK. Took a bit of playing with the lacing pattern to keep them so my heel was anchored and they come with nylon laces that don’t grip well, so you need to tie a knot that stays tied. But having figured that out I’m pleased especially for only costing me £25!

3 Likes