Poll: Which Came First For You: Radio or Mountaineering?

  • I was into radio before I got into mountaineering.
  • I was into mountaineering before I got into radio.
  • My interests in radio and mountaineering were concurrent.
  • Muffins.
0 voters
6 Likes

I also love muffins

5 Likes

Some people like cupcakes better. I for one care less for them. :wink:

3 Likes

Fun poll, but, not to be too pedantic, I wouldnā€™t ever call myself a mountaineer. I hike to summits and maybe scramble a little bit, but if it takes real mountaineering, Iā€™m not going. Greatest respect, of course, to all the real mountaineers out there who activate. For me, being outdoors, hiking and backpacking came first, radio came second.

And a vote for muffins. Write-in vote for beer, too. Not at the same time.

8 Likes

Iā€™ve been living and hiking in the mountains since I was born. Iā€™ve always had a passion for electronics, and as a kid I remember playing with walkie-talkies, designing my own PCBs, and building FM microphone transmitters.
About 10 years ago, I became interested in ā€œresilienceā€ and bought a UV-5R, programmed it, and then forgot about it in a drawer. In 2023, after moving from the city to the mountains, I realised I couldnā€™t contact anyone on 2m or 70cm due to my new topographical situation. To satisfy my curiosity (and gear acquisition syndrome), I impulsively bought an HF transceiver. However, I quickly got frustrated by my inability to transmit, so I studied for two weeks and passed the licensing exam.

Despite this, I wasnā€™t particularly interested in the conventional style of amateur radio and began exploring alternatives. Thatā€™s when I discovered SOTA, and it was a revelation. It offered the perfect combination of authentic field radio practice and a new motivation for hiking and mountaineering. Since then, my radio activity has been exclusively focused on the SOTA program.

Bonus point for the much nicer community in sota.

14 Likes

I was about one-third of the way through the quest of completing the 58 14ers in Colorado when I got my ham license and wished I had done so sooner. Now, Iā€™m doing peaks year-round, and every outing includes two adventures. Iā€™m hooked!

Ray / KD8EQA

7 Likes

Is that obese cupcakes or English muffins (what we used to call just muffins)?

5 Likes

I got sick of yelling ā€˜ON BELAYā€™ into a yawning abyss and decided a radio was the way forward.
73 Matt

9 Likes

Started in amateur radio aged 14. Licensed aged 17. Started walking hills with friends aged 15, so for me quite a close run thing.

It was the school radio club that got me into amateur radio, way back in 1966. I spent many hours sitting in front of an Eddystone 840c which was teamed up with a Heathkit DX40, homebrew ATU and a 132 foot long wire atop the school roof. I bought an 840c as a nostalgia rig around ten years ago and use it regularly for listening in the evenings.

The licence (VHF/UHFonly) came in 1969. My first portable experience apart from National Field Day at the school, was in 1971 when I went to the island of Islay with Peter G3YCT. We climbed several summits including some of those which are now SOTA summits and to which I returned to over 40 years later to activate. When we werenā€™t climbing, walking or sampling a wee dram in a distillery, we were on the air with Peter on HF and me running 2m AM with an 8 over 8 antenna. Hardly SOTA, but still good fun.

5 Likes

While I certainly appreciate your humility Tom, I would consider you to be a ā€œrealā€ mountaineer. Much in the same way that I consider a technician who only operates FM Phone on 2m a ā€œreal ham.ā€ We are all on a continuum of knowledge and experience. As long as one is actually doing it and learning along the way, I think itā€™s real.

Beyond that I think comparisons are odious.

Another country heard from,
73 Eric KG6MZS

5 Likes

Be aware that weā€™re not talking about the same thing. What Americans refer to as an ā€˜Englishā€™ muffin is not English at all, and not the same muffin you will find in British cafes, shops and homes.

The American muffin is obviously a cake, springy and soft but thereā€™s nothing like the bite on a toasted English/British muffin with its crunchy semolina floured surface.


The English muffin is yeast leavened and predates the baking powder leavened American muffins. This produces a type of muffin with a thick, fluffy pastry and is usually baked as a disk typically about 8 cm [~3"] in diameter. Add butter and/or jam to suit.

4 Likes

ā€¦ very similar. Amateur Radio aged 14, Licensed age 16, when I was more into Cycle Touring, but did more hillwalking from age 17ā€¦

4 Likes

I voted ā€œradio firstā€ on the technicality that I got my licence about a year before I took up SOTA. And it was when I took up SOTA that I starting hiking properly - boots, poles, map, compass etc.

However, Iā€™ve done both, enthusiastically as long as I can remember. My dad took me scrambling up Teggs Nose when I was about 8/9, and camping/hiking in the Lake District when I was 13. My mum would take me walking every day on the public footpaths in Mid/West Wales on camping holidays while my dad was studying his Open University books in the tent! My mum also took me on a multitude of walks around Macclesfield and Bollington.

Before I was licensed, I was a very active SWL on the amateur bands. Before that, I was keenly listening the short wave and medium wave broadcast bands for DX and international English programmes. Before that, as a teenager, I was compiling lists of what stations I could hear on the FM and MW bands. As an 8 year old I was tuning my clock radio into Radio Luxembourg each evening. My mum reckons it all started when she would put a transistor radio in my pram!

So what really came first, or what marks the start of either interest properly I have really no idea!

5 Likes

The muffin man is seated at the table, in the laboratory of the utility muffin Research kitchen. :wink:

2 Likes

Hi Andy,
image

I think thatā€™s what I would call a Crumpet (but then Iā€™m from the North of England). Of course Crumpet has another meaning in other parts of the world ā€¦

Muffin to me is one of these:
image

Oh, Iā€™m getting hungry - I wonder what is for tea?
73 Ed.

5 Likes

My earliest clear memory is walking with my parents and grandparents up to the summit of Gelligaer Common near Bargoed, though technically I was carried part of the way! This made such a deep and lasting impression on my 3 year old mind that I have loved the mountains ever since. A few years later I often roamed over what later got designated as GW/SW-024 as my Aunt lived at the foot of it - odd that I have never activated it! Radio was sparked by a crystal set when I was eleven and later a one tube TRF from a kit, so definately ā€œmountaineeringā€ came first!

As for crumpets and cupcakes, I much prefer Welshcakes!

3 Likes

Late 80s: I have a very strong interest in anything radio. I collect catalogues, dream about buying a CB and a shortwave receiver (all way out of my budget).
Early 90s: I finally buy a SW receiver (Sangean ATS-909). I seriously consider taking the amateur radio licence and buy a couple of books to prepare for the exam (and a morse learning method on a CPC6128 floppy disk!).
1996: First access to the internet. I loose my interest in radio as I realize it is becoming trivial to communicate with people around the world; I guess I assume ham radio is dead.
1996-2019: I am into hiking. I hike dozens (if not hundreds) of SOTA summits without ever having heard a word about SOTA, in Ireland, France, Spain, Polandā€¦ I donā€™t actually remember coming across ham radio in this period of my life.
February 2019: I ask a friend for advice on radios which would allow me to keep in touch with my son on ski slopes; he suggests a Baofeng UV-5R; I realize you need a license to operate it and I wonder what the state of amateur radio is. I spend a few weeks reading all about licenses, equipment, modes etc. I end up accidentally on the SOTA page. I have an epiphany moment (literally). I know this is exactly what I want to do. I focus all my free time on what it takes to get there.
June 2019: I have my license and I activate my first summit, without having spoken yet to any other ham. I learned everything from the internet.

The rest is history :rofl:

12 Likes

If itā€™s baked and takes butter and or marmalade, Iā€™m there for it whatever itā€™s called!

2 Likes

Oh dear Ed, rookie mistake ā€¦

Theyā€™re about the same size and have craters or holes. The differences are that crumpets are always made with milk (you wonā€™t find any milk in English muffin recipes) and are only griddled on one side, leaving one side toasted and the other softā€”think sort of like a pancakeā€™s texture, only a little more spongy. Crumpet recipes donā€™t require yeast, and they have a looser batter. Theyā€™re also served whole, while (English/British) muffins are split. As for English muffins, they have a breadier texture and are toasted on both sides.

[P.S. all info courtesy of the internet. I donā€™t make them, I only eat them]

6 Likes

A perfectly acceptable alternative topping to jam, especially at breakfast time.

4 Likes