One wet pig and ptwenty ptarmigans

Preparations

Originally I was planning on doing some of the Ben Lawers summits, and Fraser, @MM0EFI, and I had even agreed on the “two cars; once through” hike. However, as the weather looked mixed, I was persuaded to save that for a better day, plus one where I had time for dinner at the hotel afterwards. :clinking_beer_mugs:

As Fraser is getting close to completing all the Cairngorms National Park summits, he suggested we went there instead. He only had five left, which included The Sow of Atholl, GM/CS-078, and Geal-Charn, GM/CS-043. A route between the two, including the other two SOTA summits of Beinn Udlamain, GM/CS-022, and Sgairneach Mhor, GM/CS-028, plus a quick detour to visit the unprominent A’ Mharconaich munro, soon began to form the day before. We considered a two car route for these but instead decided a shared car ride, and a 4 km walk along the A9, would be best. As the forecast was low cloud, and rain showers in the morning, we decided to walk the A9 section first, and start with The Sow. Plus we get the road part out of the way first.

:pig: The Sow

After meeting at our establish rendezvous point, and driving around to the parking spot by the Balsporran B&B, we set off up the A9 towards The Pass of Drumochter. This is the highest point of the A9, at 460m, and also the highest mainline railway track - ask Fraser for more. Also features a burger van in the south side layby, should you need. The weather was damp but not much rain as we walked along on the road.


Once over the Allt Coire Dhomhain, the path disappears and it’s a DIY effort up to the top. At this point the rain came to join the wind. :cloud_with_rain: With a wee cairn at the top, there’s not much shelter. Hoping for a quick activation, we decided to share the HT and try 2m. After several CQs with no response, it was clear HF was going to be needed. Whilst Fraser continued on VHF, I setup HF and we managed to get enough contacts on 40m each before making a hasty descent off the summit.


Sgairneach Mhor - Munro :one:

Once we were off the summit, the weather started to improve, and by the time we were on Sgairneach Mhor, we had good views all around and even spots of blue sky!


It was here that we saw our first pair of ptarmigans, trotting along the path.

Determined to work someone on 2m, Fraser setup at the top with the slim G again. I went straight to HF and had a quick run on 40m. After a disappointing 20 minutes on 2m, with only Andy, GM6ZAK, on the Tay bridge in the log, Fraser had a quick go on 20m to get his four. Time to move on!


Beinn Udlamain - Munro :two:

Now we’re on the main munro loop, the track was clear and wide to the summit of the highest peak of the day. At 1,010m it just sneaks into the 8-pointer category. After using my radio for the previous two summits, Fraser was determined to use his own gear this time. A QMX plus a new EFHW for 20m. I left him at a post to setup whilst I went up to the summit cairn.


A glorious cairn it is too - a 4 bedroom, 3 bath, type of cairn. Whilst the rain had long gone, the wind was still strong, and definetly had an autumn temperature to it, so it was nice to setup on the leeward side.

I started on 40m again, and as Fraser hadn’t appeared, I switched to 15m. The silence of 15m made me realise how noisy the static on 40m was. It was about 1pm by now and 15m was in reasonble shape, with my highlight being @W4GO in Virginia.

Turns out Fraser didn’t have much luck with his QMX, and couldn’t transmit, so was back on my radio to get a quick four before we continued on.

A’ Mharconaich - Munro :three:

Whilst not a SOTA summit, given its 114 m prominence, it is an impressive summit when viewed from the northeast, and it would be silly not to call in as we’re passing. It was unactivated in the HEMA scheme - and remains unactivated still :sweat_smile:. We admired the view - spotting Cairn Toul in the distance, plus many other CNP summits north and east. We even meet a few other walkers.

Time is marching on⌚, and so should we🚶‍♂️‍➡️. We retrace some of our steps before heading down and then starting the final ascent.

Geal-charn - Munro :four:

Determined to (a) use his own radio gear he’s carried around all day and (b) to get some 2m contacts, Fraser once again sets up his slim G. I’m back on HF and start with 15m, but it’s much poorer for me and only two in the log. 40m was very busy, and hard to find a gap and then hard to hear over all the QRM.

At this point Fraser appears empty handed, and I pass the mic so he gets on 20m. He finished the day with a pile up on 20m, and so it’s time to head back to the car - oh I’m glad we did the A9 walk this morning!

Before we get off the summit plateau, and start descending on the path river/bog back to the car, we stumble into a covey of ptarmigans superbly camouflaged in the rocks. If they hadn’t moved, I don’t think we would’ve seen them.

Back to the car, and back home - unfortunately we didn’t have time for Fraser’s red pudding supper - so we had to finish the mince pies instead.

and Finally…

Not as many points as the Ben Lawers route, but every time we looked in its direction, it was in the clouds. We seemed to get the better weather sooner, as the cloud started lifting from west to east. We did manage 26 km, 5 summits, 4 munros, 1 corbett, 4 SOTA qualifications, and 6 mince pies.

I hope Archie, GM4KNU, has a good time on Sunday when he’s out on three of them! Fraser says don’t bother with 2m. :sweat_smile:

22 Likes

It looks like it’s gained some more scrap iron since I was there 14 years back. 14 years, it can’t be so long!

Somewhat impressive route in all there chaps :wink:

4 Likes

…great report and photos; terrific selfies. Well done guys :clap:

cheers :clinking_beer_mugs:

Geoff vk3sq

2 Likes

A grand day out…

Great pics looking over to Ben Alder :+1:

3 Likes

There was another heap between Beinn Udlamain and A’ Mharconaich. We talked about who bothered to gather it all up but then just leave it on the side of the mountain.

I assumed it was from olden times when fences were up and when they got taken down the owners just left it on the hill as they didn’t want to pay to get rid of it.

Perhaps it’s just been a series of walkers or keen beans wanting to tidy up.

I suppose one big pile of iron posts is better than them spread out hiding in the longer grass to trip you up. Or as Arlo Guthrie sang in 1967 “And we decided that one big pile is better than two little piles, and rather than bring that one up we decided to throw our’s down.”

Normally the hills that qualify for SOTA and the ones that miss out don’t bother me at all. But I do feel a bit short-changed that A’Mharconaich isn’t valid. Especially as I tagged it when I did Beinn Udlamein as well. Geal-charn, A’Mharconaich and Beinn Udlamain would be a nice round 20 points.

I can’t remember who told me that it was quicker to take the A’Mharconaich path from the end of the path from Balsporran/Geal-charn and then bimble up and down to Beinn Udlamein rather than taking whatever climbs out of the coll as there’s more path and easier ground. They were right!

2 Likes

Great report and loads of great snaps! :ok_hand:

I confess I had to look up what a Ptarmigan actually was. Learned something new, so thanks for that! First thing that came to my mind was Phteven the sausage dog. :sweat_smile:

1 Like

I was looking up recipes. Looked like they had good eating on them!

5 Likes

Matt,

I was thinking they would make a nice dinner. Not sure if roasting is better than grilling. If they are a bit tough then a stew might be best.

Would you recommend an accompanying Chardonnay from Hawkes Bay or one from the South Island?

73

Ron

VK3AFW

2 Likes

They taste remarkably like Swan.

3 Likes

OK Andy,

You have been fortunate to sample both. A roast swan is a fine meal. One of my grandfathers ate his share in his time. All black ones of course.

I found one reference that described the ptarmigan meat as dark with a slight bitter taste. Considering their habitant I think that’s apt. I’d be a bit dark and bitter if I had to live outdoors in those highlands.

The Icelanders like them for Christmas instead of turkey. The Icelandic government has restricted their hunting as they were becoming endangered. Preferable to Puffins apparently.

73

Ron

VK3AFW

2 Likes

Are they not salted, like Guga?

1 Like

No that’s Eagle or Osprey :wink:

You have to add your own salt. Gannet taste strongly of fish so a heavy salting might be required. Why not just smoke them if you want to preserve them.
Seabirds are an acquired taste.

2 Likes

The p on ptarmigan was added later by Sir Robert Sibbald. Perhaps to make it “sound” more interesting after people weren’t interested in calling a blue whale after him.

Only those on St. Kilda ever chose to eat them.

1 Like

The men of the Outer Hebrides still hunt seabirds to this day. Guga - pickled gannet.

https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/scottish-food

My Notes on the day out

I probably wasn’t looking forward to this one too much. Four potentially dull Munros that I’d climbed decades before, preceded by a nasty looking Corbett. A rubbish weather forecast, with rain and strong winds. Walking down the busy A9 for 4km. I’d activated two of the summits previously as well. It wasn’t stacking up well in my head!

Well, the Sow was a pig of a climb, but in reality the steep part was only about 15 minutes of breathless slog. The steep descent and re-ascent to Sgairneach Mhor wasn’t as bad as expected, thanks to a bit of a path and a nice land bridge across the glen between the two summits.

Once the first Munro had been climbed, we were heading home with every step. Also, it makes sense to do the four munros when you’re up there - all the effort has been made getting to the first one and it’s easy walking thereafter.

What Alex failed to mention is that we were on a strict time schedule and he had to be home for 7pm. We were on schedule to the minute until we left the fourth (non-SOTA) summit. We arrived at the last top about 15 minutes late, and thanks to my failure on 2m and having to go over to Alex’ cairn (he was 100m away) to use his radio, we ended up losing more time. This wasn’t helped by fading on 20m, which felt like the whole world was trying to work one another on my frequency at times. Then, after a couple of QSY’s, I had a mighty pile up.

We ended up leaving the top 30 minutes behind schedule, but made some time up by running, sliding and swimming down to the car in only45 minutes.

We still had 15 minutes to make up on the journey home. Gizmo the GTI had to behave on the A9, but once we reached Grantown-on-Spey and empty roads, sports mode was unleashed and another 15 minutes was gained over the twisty Bridge of Brown and Lecht road back to Strathdon.

I believe Alex arrived home at 1902h. :sweat_smile:

It was actually a fab day out in the end. We had views all the way once the rain stopped. My QMX failure seemed to have been caused by a dodgy connection in the mic.

As for 2m FM, well we’ll not talk about that. Where was everyone?

Thanks to Andy @GM6ZAK for the one VHF QSO and for attempting a second one.

5 Likes

The first ptarmigan I ever saw was in a winter descent of Bidean nam Bian, it was hunkered down in a snow patch, unnoticed in its winter plumage, and waited to the very last second before exploding up from under my feet making a noise like filing a cymbal - I nearly had to change my underpants!

2 Likes

Like an old photo competition from a Red Top Newspaper, how many Ptarmigan do you see! I think its 13…

And bad news for Fraser, Pitlochry chipper on the brae changed hands and gone downhill :frowning:

Great day out guys!

73 Gav

GM0GAV

2 Likes

Gavin, It was 13 ptarmigan! Well spotted. Claim your prize from @GM5ALX

I was hoping you’d be WFH on Tuesday, so was gutted when my 2m calls fell on deaf ears. Really surprised I didn’t get picked up by any of the Central Belt guys as well.

That is terrible news. The Sargeant Major chap who used to run it with military precision was superb! We wouldn’t have passed Pitlochry anyway. Google maps is always 50/50 on routing north via Aviemore or south via Pitlochry, when it comes to the Dalwhinnie area. North wins because quieter roads.

Been there once, it was very good. Sad to hear this.

1 Like