Activation #800, failure

What do I tell Tom? Fail to prepare, prepare to fail. Well I did prepare but not quite enough. No all the SOTA gear was with me, no problems there. It was access problems.

Beinn a’Mhanaich GM/SS-066 is one of the Luss hills. There’s place for a few cars at the bottom of the track or 500m along towards Loch Lomond. I’ve checked it out on Google maps and the path to the top is clear. You basically just go North along the ATV/LandRover track to the cairn. Not difficult.

Ah… but the Gairloch Military Training Area is next door to the hill. How close? Well access to the path involves crossing the gates into the training area. There are lots and lots and lots of signs warning you and there are warning lights and flags. Don’t enter when the flags are flying. Seems reasonable direction to me.

The flags were flying :frowning:

Now it seems that the boundary runs up the ridge where the path is. But to get to the path the gate was locked. Sure you can climb over the wooden ladder style but you know crossing into a firing range when the warning flags are flying and avoiding a locked gate seems like the start to a Darwin Award story. I was contemplating this when WWIII started. Well it sounded like the Omaha Beach scene from Saving Private Ryan. Lots and lots of SA80 fire. I don’t know about you but I can see the warning flag, the gate is locked and I can hear lots of weapons firing…I am NOT going into the range area. I’ll walk around

I followed around the fence and there was a faint path. And it was hard work in long grass and ascent but I just plodded on and on and on listening to WWIII. After some time the fence was veering away from the ridge line and started descending. No, no, no! I followed it for 100m or so and it was time for some more navigation work. Looking with the camera on zoom following the fence it continued descending to the valley floor. I was hoping it would swing towards the ridge. I came across a ladder style and there was a fence running at 90deg to my fence to the ridge. Well that marks off part of the range… can I cross the style. Right the other a side was a sign saying danger live fire don’t enter when flags/lights showing. Otherwise I’d have crossed and continued. My choice was to lose all the height I had gained, drop to the new foresting track,. walk in a few km and then climb up the steep (STEEP) sides to the top. Or quit.

I quit because I no longer was sure just where the boundary to the training area was and they were firing. I’d looked at the sign by the gate (I have a photo of it now) and it said “THE BOUNDARY HAS MOVED” and looking at my 1:25k OS Map and the MoD map, the training area is much greater. It used to stop before Beinn a’Mhanaich but now extends to Cruach an
t’Sidhein.

And of course… I had no plan B or I’d have done that :frowning:

Now back home I can see that the track is the boundary and in theory if you are on the track you are not in the training area. Apart from the fact you cross a locked gate and there are warning signs. And the track weaves around the signs crossing a few feet into the area at times. But it also seems that if you are on the side of the sign with the writing then you are not in the area. So I could have crossed into the area with sounds of WWIII and followed the path and been legal and probably safe.

But oh it seems like asking for a Darwin Award. Or meeting some very angry men in green.

I have the number off the sign and will ring it to see if you can find out when they will be firing. If so I’ll post it in the summit info.

Hrrumph! #800 another day.

15 Likes

Good story of common sense again Andy, well done!

To coin an old but well used SOTA phrase “The summit will still be there for next time”

Glad you are safe and not full of bullet holes :relieved:

3 Likes

You forgot your bullet proof vest. Problem solved.

2 Likes

I didn’t realise you were so inexperienced Andy. Only 799 activations? No wonder you’re only on your first failure. BTW, your failure rate (1 in 800) seems broadly similar to mine :wink:

2 Likes

It’s probably nearer 5 fails. I’m annoyed because I didn’t have a definitive map of the training area boundaries with me nor could I find one online. That was the the main reason for the failure - not knowing exactly where I could go when the range was in use. Not having a plan B was a schoolboy fail as well.

Anyway I now know my ribs are healed enough that carrying a ruck sack up a hill didn’t give me any problems even though I can still get some pain when turning over in bed. Also my biopsy scar no longer is “angry”.

5 Likes

I walked up to Black hill GM/SS-167, in the Pentlands past the range last year whilst the flags were flying and the sounds of gunfire reminded me of “Where Eagles Dare” .
There was snow around and I was carrying radio gear, it was all I could do not to call “Broadsword calling Danny Boy” instead of my usual call sign !
Andy
MM7MOX

2 Likes

I just assumed that was a thing related to being over 50 and overweight (in my case)…

2 Likes

Nah, the dog dragged me into a metal handrail at high speed and I used the side of my rib cage to stop me. I thinking possibly fractured now considering how much it hurt at times. It’s why I curtailed my last GM/NS SOTApedition.

1 Like

A PE teacher at school who told us it is not the fall that causes injuries but the things you do to stop yourself.

I last recalled that advice after self-arresting using a combination of my ice-axe and chin.

5 Likes

I’ve been in touch with the Range Control office. The official position is the path is outside of the range and can be accessed even if the flags are flying / lights are flashing. That means it would have been OK to climb over the 2m fence to pass the locked gate and walk up the path.

This is the range area on my older OS 1:25k map

The range now extends North along the path to Beinn a’Mhanaic and on Cruarch an T-Sidhein. If you are on the path or East of it you are outside the danger area.

Approx range border (blue) now.

I’m not going to post the range number because you can guarantee it will change and an out of date number is no use. However, the web page I used is probably less likely to change. The guy I spoke to was exceptionally helpful about access.

You can ring and ask if the range is in use for a day or so ahead. There is another web page with dates and times but it was for August so I’m not posting it.

DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH BEFORE YOU GO.

Images (c) Ordnance Survey 2024

6 Likes

Technically that should have been the boundary has been extended, but I suppose the military brain is not the same as the civilian one. Many thanks for the heads up on this one. Hopefully Sunday 6th October will be relatively quiet and I won’t arrive at the summit with my nerves shattered.

The same goes for stalking of course… another opportunity to earn yourself a Darwin Award. :wink:

1 Like

Out of curiosity I googled whether it’s legal to go deer stalking on a Sunday. You can’t go grouse shooting on a Sunday so that’s a good time to activate if you are worried a hill may be closed. Very helpfully the generative AI at the top of the results page says:

No, it is not legal to deer stalk on a Sunday in the UK

Looking at the other search results shows that that is complete rubbish! Once again AI is proven to be useless.

Having said that you are much less likely to be shot by a deer stalker on a Sunday as it is often frowned upon.

1 Like

It’s not customary to go deer stalking on a Sunday. North Chesthill Estate excepted :wink:

2 Likes

The ongoing discussion in many quarters! If I ever get to do the GM/CS-019 + GM/CS-016 round, then I think timing will be a very important consideration. Hillwalking Access | Chesthill Estate

1 Like