About CW speed and more ...

I agree but I know [from previous discussions] others differ on this, e.g. Guru @EA2IF

My motivation for getting my head-copying up to 21-25wpm is not to activate faster [sending at 20wpm is about right for my QRP signal on compromise antennas] but to be able to chase QRQ activators and to understand those QRQ chasers who won’t slow to my sending speed.

1 Like

I feel the same way… about 20 wpm is a good speed for me when I do standard qso. But as soon as a longer question comes up and I am not ready to write, I am stuck. I have to be able to take notes.
Anything much faster - but also much slower - throws me out of the rhythm.

Fortunately, my KX2 can comfortably adjust the speed for giving. So I can immediately adjust to slow giving partners. However, I make more mistakes below my usual speed.

With a strong pileup on the summit, it is rarely the signal strength that makes me reach for the chaser. It is the tone, the rhythm, the quality of the CW character… and of course a well-known letter combination. So known chasers sometimes have an advantage.

…chasers who call me with very high (for me too high) speed, I can also ignore well.

73 Armin

1 Like

Do you mean I support QRQ when SOTA activating?

1 Like

Ok here’s my 2 penorth for what it’s worth. I’ts more of a quest for advice more than anything.
I have made very few contacts in CW on Sota so I don’t know if my procedure is right or wrong !
Ok I will listen for the activator then I will send such as this :- 2E0AGB 2E0AGB PLS K
NAME HR ALLEN ALLEN BTU
TNX UR RST 5NN 5NN BTU
RR 73 SK E E

I send at 18 wpm

Please advice would be appreciated.

2 Likes

Hi Guru,

I can’t find the thread where you and I discussed this previously - but you expressed the view then that you prefer to activate at higher speeds [25+wpm I think] because you get through more contacts quickly. You also said you slow down for QRS chasers [which I know you do from my QSOs with you].

73 Andy

1 Like

And whilst searching for that old dialogue we had on CW speed I found some good advice you gave on head copying …

1 Like

The best way to learn is to listen!

Often you have a strong pile up on the sota or you don’t want to stay on the summit for too long. So the sota qsos are usually quite short and reduced to the essential.
The essential means here that the call of the chaser is confirmed and a rst is given. Usually you say goodbye with 73 - but that’s it.

I call - cq sota de dl6gca/p

You only answer - 2e0agb

I heard you, confirm your call and give you a rst - 2e0agb 559 559 bk (i prefer to send the real rst and no 5nn)

You have heard your call confirmed and rst and know that I listen to you and confirm for me - bk 2e0agb 539 539 73

I say goodbye - 73

This is the normal procedure if you are in a hurry as an activator (strong pile up, several summits planned a day, bad weather, moody wife,…) …otherwise you can take your time

73 Armin

4 Likes

Nope, it must have been somebody else, I think. Actually, I activate around 22-20 WPM because I know weak signals like the ones coming from a QRP station are better copied if QRS. I have even written some posts recommending US activators to go QRS because I like chasing North-American activators and I’ve experienced that when they go QRQ (25 WPM) and their signal is at about the noise floor level, it’s is just impossible for me to get the code they are sending. On the other hand, a 20 WPM morse is much easier to copy in those extremely weak signal conditions.
It will be interesting to find that thread to see what I wrote there. If you find it, let me know, please.
Thank you.
73,

Guru

2 Likes

Hi Allen,
This seems a bit too long for a standard SOTA chase.
I’d recommend you to shorten it to the following:
When the activator stops sending and listens for chasers, you send your call once or twice, depending on the pileup size and the signal strength you guess you’ll be putting on the activator receiver. Just your callsign without PSE K or any other sign.
Once the activator answered to you with a signal report, you come back with R R or QSL to let him know he got your callsign correct and you got his report correct. Then you can send GM/GA/GE (Good morning/afternoon/evening) followed by the activator’s name if you know it. Then UR 599 or whatever signal report you want to give him and 73 GL (Good luck) TU or BK (back to him)
He will say CFM or QSL or similar and 73 TU. Then you’ll have just finished you QSO.
That’s it.

I hope this helps you.
73,

Guru

5 Likes

Hi Guru, I found that discussion.

From memory I thought it was 25+wpm but in fact it was 22wpm - which probably seemed fast to me back then [Q4 '17] when I first started SOTA activations around 15wpm. Now 22wpm seems achievable to me.

2 Likes

Hi Armin and Guru. Thanks ever so much for your replies, I have taken what you say on board and yes looking at how I have been doing it ,now that you’ve both explained makes so much sense so a Big Thanks to both of you. Stay safe and all the very best 73

Allen

1 Like

Thanks, Andy, for bringing that post back here. Well, it confirms quite well what I just wrote above in this thread. At the present time my FT-817 keyer speed is set to 20 WPM and it’s been like that for quite some time (i.e. several activations)
This morning I activated with my MTR-2B and I think I went at about 22 WPM. I know it’s possible to change the speed, but I’ve never done it yet on this MTR and I don’t know how to do it. I know it’s explained in the manual but I haven’t got a chance or the mood to look at it yet.
73,

Guru

3 Likes

Hi Eric! There are both sides. I’m honest with you, I love QRQ (40wpm in contests and 30wmp in SOTA) and when I reply to someone who transmits slower I often forget to slow down. Why? because for me the CW is like talking, I can’t think in dahs and dits, for me it is something musical and rhythmic. For example, if I go to France with very basic French, you will not speak to me slower but you will use easier terms.
Unfortunately the CW in most cases is poorly (or baddly) taught. I have read that many start at very slow speeds and this is counterproductive as it limits you to operate at a maximum of 15wpm in the future. The CW should not be learned as something mathematical but should be learned as a new language.
I think these are some reasons why many do not slow down. I understand that we have to slow down to people who answer us more slowly. But instead of a problem of values ​​I think it is a mismatch of customs.
73 Takeo

3 Likes

Hi Takeo San @JP3PPL

Thanks for your reply and I understand your point of view.
But I was mostly talking about SOTA, and for those who one day decide to switch to The CW. Due to the behavior of some hunters it can disgust them …
Just a reminder !

For my part I have no problem, I can at the same time do a CW QSO and answer my wife who came to ask me a question about a cooking recipe. :wink:

73 Éric

3 Likes

Got it! Sadly these are the display operators (decoders) and many of them know absolutely nothing about CW tips.
I am not at all against the new CW ops helping themselves with decoders, but if they do not know the basics, it is preferable that they do not operate.

3 Likes

Hi Eric

Catching up with CW is a project for me for the time after retirement at the latest. From time to time I listen to the CW SOTA frequencies to “suck in the music”.

I am pretty sure that I will cope quickly with a reasonable pace, since I will base on those 4 CW QSOs done 33 years ago, hi, so I won’t have a starting point at 0.0%. But there is that a bit difficult period in between where I must build up my ability, and I certainly will be happy with those partners who know where/how they can reduce the CW speed on their device and who certainly know what “QRS” means. But this is something in the future, the rat race wheel at my QRL turns too fast at present.

So looking forward to meet the pros like you somewhen for SOTA! :+1:

Vy 73 de Markus, HB9DIZ

2 Likes

Hi,

I will try to say a few things as I see them with regard to cw.
First of all I admire the activators, their cw, sending as well as copy/understanding is very, very good, outstanding in fact, generally I would say magna cum laude.

I chase the activators with qrp and a simple antenna, well the use of qrp limits the maximum cw speed one can use, I would say somewhere between 20 and 24 wpm, I use 24 wpm.

Head copy is something that comes automatically, starting with things that you hear on a everyday base, like 5NN, RST, name QTH etc.
My experience is that your capability to copy and send drops as soon as you leave the standard qso and enter free text/ragchew.

Good advice is to record from time to time your own cw sending and check the quality of your sending.
A recording device can also be useful to record your qsos, so if there are parts you did not copy 100% sure, you can hear them again.

One of the things that annoy me the most, and thats outside of SOTA is an operator who calls cq and after sending pse k is listening only for a second or 2 before starting again calling cq. At 24 wpm I can barely squeeze in the prefix of my call in the time he is not sending. This one can hear on a single day dozens of times without effort.

And last but not least a lot of operators outside SOTA are allergic against any remarks with respect to their operating techniques.

3 Likes

You’ve obviously not worked me while I’ve been activating sheltering from the horizontal driving rain! :grinning:

I do generally agree with your comment Patrick. Unfortunately my experience has been the poor standards exhibited by chasers who latch on to the fact that the SOTA summit area also applies to the scheme they are interested in. How many times recently have I heard appeals for these ops to listen!

1 Like

I’ve heard that professional CW radio operators have this ability [or had? - do they exist anymore?]. Meanwhile, the rest of us mere morals will admire that but also be jealous.

2 Likes

Hi Gerald G4OIG,
Chasing SOTA with QRP is not easy, especially when there is a pile up. The difficulty is with qrp you cannot penetrate the QRO pile up, so I try to place my call sending when the calling qrm in the pile up is getting weaker, but in doing so there is a risk to disturb the activator qso that might already be in progress. But far more often it is exercising patience and waiting until the pile up is over and hoping the activator is not going qsy fast.
For me with qrp I get best results during the week (less chasers) compared to weekends.
Paradise situation would be if the activator is not only regularly asking any /P stations? But also asking any QRP chasers?

2 Likes