I would just make them both to compare on a summit, I have a storage box for my antennas collections/spares, you will always be wondering how the other would have compared. This is one of my many enjoyments of being an activator is having the space on a summit with no restrictions to setup and try different antennas.
Could be worse you could be looking to purchase a new rig so many choices these days.
My list
Linked dipole 40/30/20/17
Trapped EFHW 20/30/40
EFHW cut for 20m
Norcal Doublet
Another doublet for 80m
20m ¹¼ vertical
Buddipole clone Jac3 antenna
A 100m roll of sotabeams antenna wire (gonna need a bigger box)
73
Graeme