QSPing is a bad habit for anyone to get into. However, in this case Mike you heard the report from Al directly therefore it is a valid QSO regardless of whether you heard the QSP as well. Because of the vast QRM on top of Al I was also unsure of the validity of my QSO with Al so worked him on 10Mhz for Gud QSO.
I heard both sides and Al was patient with stations throwing their calls in whilst he was trying to get his 559 over to you. He tried moving up and down a bit until you finally managed to copy it. Anyway, the only person to be satisfied that the contact was good is yourself, so put it in the data-base without concern.
Just to be sure you wisely made an insurance contact on 10.116 a few mins later so there can be no complaints!
To be honest I’d already made the decision that I wasn’t going to claim the 40m QSO even though I had heard the rprt direct from AL, just in case it put anyone in doubt.
As you know I have since made a second QSO (insurance) with Al and got chance to explain to him what had happened, so the contact is now 100% good.
I think this lid is very close to me, and both Steve GW7AAV and myself have been affected by him/her in the past.
…but to relay a report they have to be able to read it as well!
You can get machines to do that as well of course! Although nowhere near as well as a highly-trained brain/ear combination…
I have very occasionally had someone try to QSP a report on voice contacts - as said previously, no doubt the QSP’er thinks they are helping but it’s help I would rather do without.
I remember telling a station he made a good contact after he confirmed the report correctly, after a very difficult QSO. As I did not tell the report myself that is not cheating I guess.